Wednesday , June 16 2021

Asssin & # 39; s Creed Odyssey Vs. "Red Dead Redemption 2": Comparison of graphics




<div _ngcontent-c14 = "" innerhtml = "

"Assassin & # 39; s Creed Odyssey"Credit: Ubisoft / Kevin Murnane

October was reserved by two unique open-world games, Assassin & # 39; s Creed Odyssey and Red Dead Redemption II. Both contain rich stories embedded in beautifully rendered worlds in which everything is full of things to do. Both games are similar on this wide level of description, but their visual presentations are very different. I compare the two in graphic terms and consider efficiency and gameplay in future articles.

Odyssey and RDR2 they are characterized by a brilliant artistic direction and an excellent graphic presentation. When it comes to comparing consoles, both games tell a familiar story. They look best on the Xbox One X, then in descending order through PS4 Pro, the PS4 base and Xbox One S. However, the order of the console does not tell the true story. In its own way, Odyssey and RDR2 provide a clear demonstration that in a duel, One X does not have real competition in the current generation of console when it comes to putting great-looking games on the screen. Therefore, this article focuses on how Odyssey and RDR2 take a look at One X.

"Assassin & # 39; s Creed Odyssey"Credit: Ubisoft

Schedule

Resolution is important for games such as Assassin & # 39; s Creed Odyssey and Red Dead Redemption II they combine a realistic design with open worlds of large scale and detail. Lighting models, texture properties and LODS (detail levels), thanks to which spectacular views of the game and subtly detailed interiors and character models come to life, all have a positive effect on increasing the resolution. If you sit the right distance from the 4K screen. Odyssey and RDR2 they are incredibly nice-looking games.

Assassin & # 39; s Creed Odyssey and Red Dead Redemption II Resolution of handles in various ways. Odyssey it targets 4K in One X and Pro and uses dynamic scaling to reduce the resolution if needed to maintain frame rates. Digital Foundry he cataloged the lowest, highest and average resolutions observed for four consoles. Here are their results expressed as a percentage of the full 4K (3840 x 2160). It can be a table with the number of pixels for each category find here for interested.

Console Short Average Tall
Xbox One X 59% 64% 100%
PS4 Pro 33% 44% 54%
PS4 17% (69%) Not reported 25% (100%)
Xbox One 12% (49%) Not reported 17% (69%)

The One X reaches full 4K, but does not do it often. The striking aspect of comparing consoles is that One X at the worst is slightly better than Pro at its best.

"Red Dead Redemption II"Credit: Rockstar Games

RDR2 does not use dynamic resolution scaling. Instead, it renders at different resolutions on each console, and then uses post-processing techniques to increase resolution when needed. They're here RDR2The number of pixels and the percentage of 4K for four consoles.

Console rendering Percentage 4K
Xbox One X 3840 x 2160 100%
PS4 Pro 1920 x 2160 50%
PS4 1920×1080 25%
Xbox One S 1536 x 864 16%

The One X renders RDR2 in full 4K during the game. None of the others are close. Pro uses a kind of chessboard solution to increase the resolution to 4K, but the technique worsens the image compared to the full 4K One X rendering.

"Red Dead Redemption II"Credit: Rockstar Games

Temporal smoothing

Higher resolution images are more detailed and refined. There is more on the screen than in 4K. In addition, the resolution has a positive effect on other visual features, such as lighting and LODS. Resolution also interacts with temporal smoothing, but here interaction can have a negative effect.

Temporal anti-aliasing uses information from previous and subsequent frames to smooth curved and diagonal lines as well as smooth motion as these lines move on the screen. Odyssey and RDR2 both use this technique.

Temporal smoothing smudges some small details in a 4K image, which softens the image. Blur becomes more noticeable when resolution drops. The decrease in image quality is almost invisible RDR2Full 4K render on One X. This is a bit more of a problem on Pro, but it is relatively small and the advantages outweigh the disadvantages. Blur becomes a serious problem when you reach the low resolution seen on the One S.

The effect of temporary smoothing in Odyssey it is more difficult to evaluate because the resolution decreases as the CPU load increases. This technique will most likely have the greatest negative impact in scenes with high traffic, in which a lot is happening. However, these are also scenes where the least noticeable decrease in the quality of the image is because your attention is taken through the actions displayed on the screen.

Luminance map "Assassin & # 39; s Creed Odyssey".Credit: Digital Foundry

HDR

The HDR implementation is the main force Assassin & # 39; s Creed OdysseyVisual presentation. This is an epic failure Red Dead Redemption II.

Engineers involved in graphics at Ubisoft have an in-depth knowledge of HDR and really appear in it Odyssey. The sunny, Mediterranean environments of Greece are beautifully displayed with subtle light effects, bright colors and more details in light and dark areas.

Odyssey it also has a first pair of HDR controls, so players can match the presentation to their personal preferences and screen characteristics. One control associates the HDR with the maximum brightness that the screen can display and the other sets the white level. Guide to set up OdysseyHDR control can be found here.

Assassin & # 39; s Creed Odyssey is a master class in the field of proper HDR performance. Red Dead Redemption II is an amazing example of how to screw it up.

Actually, RDR2 it does not really spoil HDR, because the game does not do HDR at all. Sends the SDR image to the console and marks it as HDR. As good as RDR2 it looks – and looks very, very good – it would look much better if it was in HDR.

The absence of HDR makes RDR2 they look darker, have darker colors and fewer details in bright and dark areas of the screen than if HDR was in the game. What's more, labeling its SDR output as HDR tells the console and screen to treat the image as HDR, which can negatively affect the image quality depending on how the equipment processes the HDR input. Finally, RDR2Control "HDR" is really a brightness control that can degrade the image more than it improves.

A clear visual comparison of the effect of HDR Odyssey and RDR2 may be find hereand a more in-depth discussion RDR2HDR problem with what you can do to fix it & nbsp; available here.

"Red Dead Redemption II"Credit: Digital Foundry

Which game looks best?

Assassin & # 39; s Creed Odyssey and Red Dead Redemption II are at or near the top of the list of best-looking games released so far on & nbsp; today's consoles. Which one is preferred is a matter of personal choice. No matter which one you like best, you will see the game as it should be visible on One X. All other consoles are lowered.

Gram Odyssey and RDR2 on One X and I sit with my eyes within a few inches optimal distance from the 65-inch LG OLED 4K display. Thanks to this configuration I prefer RDR2Native 4K render to OdysseyUses dynamic resolution scaling. I would like to be able to choose a different form of anti-aliasing on both consoles. I do not know if it would look better, but I would like to find out. With every configuration, OdysseyThe beautiful HDR implementation is infinitely better RDR2It is false.

Given this, I think both Assassin & # 39; s Creed Odyssey and Red Dead Redemption II there are beautiful games. I am more aware of HDR failure RDR2 than the resolution falls in Odyssey when I play, but even after many hours of playing, I am regularly stopped in my songs by the breathtaking visual effects in both games. Unfortunately, the hostile people in & nbsp;Odyssey and RDR2 they are not so easily impressed, so I am regularly restrained on the leggins, while I am blissed at nice.

Interested & nbsp;Readers may want to view detailed technical analysis from Digital Foundry Assassin & # 39; s Creed Odyssey on One X and Pro or One S and PS4along with them comparison of four consoles with Red Dead Redemption 2.

KassandraCredit: Ubisoft

if you are interested& nbsp;Assassin & # 39; s Creed Odysseyhere are some articles you may like.

And for Red Dead Redemption II.

">

"Assassin & # 39; s Creed Odyssey"Credit: Ubisoft / Kevin Murnane

October was reserved by two unique open-world games, Assassin & # 39; s Creed Odyssey and Red Dead Redemption II. Both contain rich stories embedded in beautifully rendered worlds in which everything is full of things to do. Both games are similar on this wide level of description, but their visual presentations are very different. I compare the two in graphic terms and consider efficiency and gameplay in future articles.

Odyssey and RDR2 they are characterized by a brilliant artistic direction and an excellent graphic presentation. When it comes to comparing consoles, both games tell a familiar story. They look best on the Xbox One X, then in descending order through PS4 Pro, the PS4 base and Xbox One S. However, the order of the console does not tell the true story. In its own way, Odyssey and RDR2 provide a clear demonstration that in a duel, One X does not have real competition in the current generation of console when it comes to putting great-looking games on the screen. Therefore, this article focuses on how Odyssey and RDR2 take a look at One X.

"Assassin & # 39; s Creed Odyssey"Credit: Ubisoft

Schedule

Resolution is important for games such as Assassin & # 39; s Creed Odyssey and Red Dead Redemption II they combine a realistic design with open worlds of large scale and detail. Lighting models, texture properties and LODS (detail levels), thanks to which spectacular views of the game and subtly detailed interiors and character models come to life, all have a positive effect on increasing the resolution. If you are sitting at a suitable distance from the 4K screen, Odyssey and RDR2 they are incredibly nice-looking games.

Assassin & # 39; s Creed Odyssey and Red Dead Redemption II Resolution of handles in various ways. Odyssey it targets 4K in One X and Pro and uses dynamic scaling to reduce the resolution if needed to maintain frame rates. Digital Foundry has cataloged the lowest, highest and average resolutions observed for four consoles. Here are their results expressed as a percentage of the full 4K (3840 x 2160). A table with the number of pixels for each category can be found here for those interested.

Console Short Average Tall
Xbox One X 59% 64% 100%
PS4 Pro 33% 44% 54%
PS4 17% (69%) Not reported 25% (100%)
Xbox One 12% (49%) Not reported 17% (69%)

The One X reaches full 4K, but does not do it often. The striking aspect of comparing consoles is that One X at the worst is slightly better than Pro at its best.

"Red Dead Redemption II"Credit: Rockstar Games

RDR2 does not use dynamic resolution scaling. Instead, it renders at different resolutions on each console, and then uses post-processing techniques to increase resolution when needed. They're here RDR2The number of pixels and the percentage of 4K for four consoles.

Console rendering Percentage 4K
Xbox One X 3840 x 2160 100%
PS4 Pro 1920 x 2160 50%
PS4 1920×1080 25%
Xbox One S 1536 x 864 16%

The One X renders RDR2 in full 4K during the game. None of the others are close. Pro uses a kind of chessboard solution to increase the resolution to 4K, but the technique worsens the image compared to the full 4K One X rendering.

"Red Dead Redemption II"Credit: Rockstar Games

Temporal smoothing

Higher resolution images are more detailed and refined. There is more on the screen than in 4K. In addition, the resolution has a positive effect on other visual features, such as lighting and LODS. Resolution also interacts with temporal smoothing, but here interaction can have a negative effect.

Temporal anti-aliasing uses information from previous and subsequent frames to smooth curved and diagonal lines as well as smooth motion as these lines move on the screen. Odyssey and RDR2 both use this technique.

Temporal smoothing smudges some small details in a 4K image, which softens the image. Blur becomes more noticeable when resolution drops. The decrease in image quality is almost invisible RDR2Full 4K render on One X. This is a bit more of a problem on Pro, but it is relatively small and the advantages outweigh the disadvantages. Blur becomes a serious problem when you reach the low resolution seen on the One S.

The effect of temporary smoothing in Odyssey it is more difficult to evaluate because the resolution decreases as the CPU load increases. This technique will most likely have the greatest negative impact in scenes with high traffic, in which a lot is happening. However, these are also scenes where the least noticeable decrease in the quality of the image is because your attention is taken through the actions displayed on the screen.

Luminance map "Assassin & # 39; s Creed Odyssey".Credit: Digital Foundry

HDR

The HDR implementation is the main force Assassin & # 39; s Creed OdysseyVisual presentation. This is an epic failure Red Dead Redemption II.

Engineers involved in graphics at Ubisoft have an in-depth knowledge of HDR and really appear in it Odyssey. The sunny, Mediterranean environments of Greece are beautifully displayed with subtle light effects, bright colors and more details in light and dark areas.

Odyssey it also has a first pair of HDR controls, so players can match the presentation to their personal preferences and screen characteristics. One control associates the HDR with the maximum brightness that the screen can display and the other sets the white level. Guide to set up OdysseyHDR control can be found here.

Assassin & # 39; s Creed Odyssey is a master class in the field of proper HDR performance. Red Dead Redemption II is an amazing example of how to screw it up.

Actually, RDR2 it does not really spoil HDR, because the game does not do HDR at all. Sends the SDR image to the console and marks it as HDR. As good as RDR2 it looks – and looks very, very good – it would look much better if it was in HDR.

The absence of HDR makes RDR2 they look darker, have darker colors and fewer details in bright and dark areas of the screen than if HDR was in the game. What's more, labeling its SDR output as HDR tells the console and screen to treat the image as HDR, which can negatively affect the image quality depending on how the equipment processes the HDR input. Finally, RDR2Control "HDR" is really a brightness control that can degrade the image more than it improves.

A clear visual comparison of the effect of HDR Odyssey and RDR2 can be found here and a more in-depth discussion about RDR2The HDR problem with what you can do to fix it is available here.

"Red Dead Redemption II"Credit: Digital Foundry

Which game looks best?

Assassin & # 39; s Creed Odyssey and Red Dead Redemption II are at the top of the list of best-looking games released so far on today's consoles. Which one is preferred is a matter of personal choice. No matter which one you like best, you will see the game as it should be visible on One X. All other consoles are lowered.

Gram Odyssey and RDR2 on One X and I sit with my eyes a few inches away from the optimal distance from the 65-inch LG OLED 4K display. Thanks to this configuration I prefer RDR2Native 4K render to OdysseyUses dynamic resolution scaling. I would like to be able to choose a different form of anti-aliasing on both consoles. I do not know if it would look better, but I would like to find out. With every configuration, OdysseyThe beautiful HDR implementation is infinitely better RDR2It is false.

Given this, I think both Assassin & # 39; s Creed Odyssey and Red Dead Redemption II there are beautiful games. I am more aware of HDR failure RDR2 than the resolution falls in Odyssey when I play, but even after many hours of playing, I am regularly stopped in my songs by the breathtaking visual effects in both games. Unfortunately, hostile residents Odyssey and RDR2 they are not so easily impressed, so I am regularly restrained on the leggins, while I am blissed at nice.

Interested Readers may want to view detailed technical analysis from Digital Foundry Assassin & # 39; s Creed Odyssey on One X and Pro or One S and PS4, along with their four console comparisons Red Dead Redemption 2.

if you are interested Assassin & # 39; s Creed Odysseyhere are some articles you may like.

And for Red Dead Redemption II.


Source link